So, You're Planning to Sell Your Collection of LPs?

A time for downsizing may come in your life, as it did in mine. If you’ve spent decades enjoying vinyl, you may find yourself staring at shelves upon shelves of records that, sooner or later, will need to find a new home. In my case, that meant more than 8000 LPs. When we moved to an apartment, they simply couldn’t come with us. So, what do you do?

Back in 2020, I wrote about our downsizing journey in a four-part series for Positive Feedback titled Yes, There Really Is Music After Vinyl (HERE). In those articles, I told the story of our transition from diehard vinyl devotees to a fully digital listening life. What I didn’t describe in much detail was how we actually sold or gave away thousands of records.

Since then, I’ve received occasional requests from fellow music lovers asking for that part of the story. Twice, the inquiry came from a surviving spouse or adult child suddenly faced with the daunting task of liquidating an audiophile’s system and record collection—often numbering in the thousands. After a recent request, I decided it was time to write up what I learned in the hope that it may help others facing the same challenge.

The article isn’t a definitive guide, just a summary of my experience, from which you may glean a few useful ideas for your own journey. Hopefully this may be useful to some…

So, You’re Planning to Sell Your Collection of LPs?

Today, my posts here are primarily about ultra high resolution digital files in the threads Your Best DSD256 and High Definition Tape Transfer. This post struck me as too off-topic for those threads, so I’m posting it as a standalone item given the interest it has received on a couple other online audio forums.

9 Likes

I just finished your complete and outstanding PF series. I found your journey to digital fascinating and I learned alot. Your amp and headphone solution I am impressed with. Thanks for posting.

1 Like

Thanks for posting, indeed! In my case, the split with LP came decades ago with my Marantz CD75SE. People are different, and to me the two formats simply couldn’t coexist, so I so got rid of my LP collection and Linn Sondek in a flash. And 8000 LP’s? My collection did not even come close!

Today I’m finding myself in pretty much the same situation. I have “proven” to myself that downloaded material from ***tracker.org sounds the same on my PSA transport than CD. The idea of writing .flac, .dsd (etc) appealed to me (hey, like, I can cut my own “playlist” … :smiley:). Before long I found myself literally cluttered with unlabelled -R DVDs around me, and my hard drive filled with music yet to be evaluated.

Furthermore, I’ve only JUST “upgraded” from DS1 to MkII; and to SACD PST - and wow, just like that $14000 became $6000 in what, 6 months after purchase? I look at my “stack” and suddenly I see “clutter” instead of “harmony and beauty”. To cut a long story short: My BHK 300’s; BHK Pre; DS MkII, PST SACD and HiFi Rose RS150B … with Atlas Asimi interconnects are GONE! In it’s place is coming (next week) an Aurender AP20 all in one, with a little snake oil (NH10 network hub).

To me, the split is final: I have to change the way I listen to music.

1 Like

So you stayed away from the eBay madness and went with discord for the vinyl sales?

I did that for the widow of friend, I’m about to finish!

What i didn’t expect, didn’t understand, she just want to get rid of the stuff, didn’t want any money!

It took her 7 years to came at the point. Family like shark have hitting hard in the HiFi, but since they didn’t understand HiFi, keep bringing back the stuff!

For my part, I understand the Shark thing, but that all!

As I proceed with the sale, what Hit me hard by surprise, is the grief! He was my friend for many decade older than me, Cancer it his liver big [6 month], he was gone. With the help of his wife, he live in his house, until the last our!

For his final destination, he kept his eyes open all the road to the hospital in the ambulance, looking outside! arrived in the door of the hospital, he let it all go, he was gone!

But the grief, selling friend stuff, wow big hurt! As I sell, souvenir came back I never had a grief hit so hard and so long, it took me month to discard his stuff.

Would never do that again.

I have discuss that with my kids and wife for mine, and it will all go to a charity sale/yard sale. It’s will spread, I hope [I am please to think that], a bit of joy to the people who will buy it and bring it home a treasury they have searched for years!

So will never proceed again, selling stuff for a friend, to involving emotionally!

Take care, play your cards, life is short, but a record it 45 minutes [the time to drive to the Final Destination!].

4 Likes

I sold a few records on eBay, but I got a lot of low-ballers (way under asking price just trolling for a deal). So I quickly abandoned that avenue and stayed with Discogs where I pretty much got my asking prices, which I’d set reasonably and didn’t negotiate other than for some multi-item sales.

2 Likes