I’m a big fan of Micheal Fremer, his reviews, his analog setup clinics and in person, but I feel the review is flawed.
Failing to hear the Amps in balanced mode is akin to reviewing a Porsche on all season tires (instead of grippier summer tires) and then complaining that the car’s handling is off and lost grip at the apexes.
Sure one can get a decent sense of the product’s behavior but you’ll never know what that last few percent of performance was like.
I have listened to the PWD in a friends system, first single ended then balanced and it made a huge difference. Though I haven’t tried my BKH 300’s in unbalanced mode (due to cable and placement issues) I can’t possibly imagine there not being a benefit.
Even with the DS driven balanced but with the RCA’s connected to subs I found a loss of sound quality. At this level of performance, these (not so small) details matter to the final outcome.
And who is to say that the synergy between Michael’s Dartzeel preamp and the mating amp is the proper arena to judge a product against. Michael rightly used 2 different speakers to test the amps, and he should have used another source or pre (balanced) to give a fuller picture of what the amp’s true capabilities are.
As many of you have, I read though the multi year saga as Paul set out to build an amp that would compete at the highest levels, but at a price many could afford. The dream team he assembled, the groupthink and exchange of ideas has indeed created something very special, and I find the marketing hype to be appropriate.
While I haven’t heard my TAD based system powered by all the top amps, I have heard them on some very good, much more expensive and highly touted synergystic designs and the BHK is in another league. As the ancillary gear (DS and now amps) gets better, I feel like I am finally able to hear what the transducers are capable of… real sounding instruments.
I think eventually the virtues of this design will be accepted in common audiophile knowledge and I believe these amps will stand the test of time.
It’s difficult enough to create a product that performs at this level even as a cost no object design, but doing it at a real world pricing is a feat not to be dismissed so easily.